Services

Actual return statement (box 3)

Are you paying box 3 tax on a return you never actually made? Under the rebuttal scheme (tegenbewijsregeling) you can report your actual return instead. If it is lower than the deemed return the Dutch Tax Administration uses, you only pay tax on what you really earned. TaxMate calculates the actual return on your savings, investments and other assets, backs it up with the right documents and files the statement for you, so you don't pay more than you have to.

A TaxMate adviser reviews the actual box 3 return with a client at the computer

What is the actual return statement?

In box 3 the Dutch Tax Administration taxes an assumed return on your assets. With the actual return statement (opgaaf werkelijk rendement) you show what your assets really yielded in a given year. If that actual return is lower, the tax is calculated on it instead. This is the rebuttal scheme, which has been in Dutch law since 2025.

Who is it relevant for?

The scheme is especially relevant if your assets yielded little: a lot of savings at a low interest rate, investments that fell in value, or a second home with high costs. Entrepreneurs who build up assets alongside their business also sometimes pay more box 3 tax than their assets actually earned.

How does TaxMate help?

We collect the annual statements from your banks and investment accounts, calculate your actual return under the statutory rules and compare it with the deemed return. We only file the statement if the actual return comes out lower. You see in advance what it will save you, with a clear breakdown per year.

The actual return statement: tax on what you really earned

For years, box 3 tax was levied on a notional return, regardless of what your savings or investments actually produced. The Dutch Supreme Court ruled that this breaches the right to property where your actual return was lower. That is why the rebuttal scheme was introduced: you may show that your actual return was below the deemed return, and you then only pay tax on that lower amount. TaxMate checks whether that applies to you and handles the statement from start to finish.

Entrepreneur working intently on a laptop on their bookkeeping

When is it worth reporting your actual return?

Whether the statement pays off depends on how your assets are made up and how they performed in a given year. If you mainly held savings at a low interest rate, your investments fell in value or you own a second home with high costs, your actual return is often below the deemed return. In a strong year on the stock market, the deemed return is usually more favourable. That is why we run the numbers first, so you never file a statement for nothing. If the statement does come out higher, the Tax Administration applies the more favourable outcome.

Which years can you report?

For 2021 and later years, anyone can report their actual return, even without having filed an objection at the time. For 2017 up to and including 2020, this is only possible if you objected on time back then. From tax year 2025 onwards, you report your actual return in the income tax return itself. For 2024 and earlier years it goes through the separate Opgaaf werkelijk rendement form, after you have received a letter about it from the Tax Administration. TaxMate checks which years are still open for you and which route applies.

How is the actual return calculated?

The actual return is more than the interest and dividends you receive. Increases and decreases in the value of your investments and real estate also count, even if you sold nothing. Deposits and withdrawals are corrected for. Interest you pay on box 3 debts is deductible, but most other costs are not, and the tax-free allowance does not apply in this calculation. Because of these rules, the outcome can differ from what you expect. We do the full calculation and show you per component where the return comes from.

What information do you need?

You have to make your actual return plausible, so supporting evidence matters. Think of the annual statements of your bank and savings accounts, the statements of your investment or crypto accounts showing the value at the start and end of the year, details of rented-out or second homes, and the interest on any debts. You send us the documents, we check that everything is complete and keep the supporting file, so that if the Tax Administration has questions you can show straight away how the statement was put together.

Why TaxMate for your actual return statement?

The rules on the actual return are new and still developing, with ongoing case law on issues such as unrealised changes in value and personal use of property. A mistake in the calculation costs you money or leads to questions from the Tax Administration. TaxMate is a modern accounting firm that works with box 3 every day. We first check whether the statement will benefit you, prepare the full supporting file and submit the statement, with one dedicated contact who knows your situation.

Reporting your actual return?

Only pay box 3 tax on what you really earned.

Was the return on your savings or investments lower than the deemed return? TaxMate calculates whether the actual return statement pays off for you, prepares the supporting evidence and files the statement, with one dedicated contact.

  • All tax returns filed on time
  • Dedicated point of contact
  • Insight via MyTaxMate dashboard
  • No hidden costs
9.7On Trustoo
24hResponse time
1,000+Satisfied clients
Book a free consultation

Your personal point of contact, always available.

Leave your details and tell us briefly what you need help with. We will get back to you.

9.7 on Trustoo and 4.8 on TrustpilotNo obligation24h response time
Call usE-mail